American households expect to spend more in the year ahead — not because they plan to buy more, but because they expect everything to cost more, according to a Federal Reserve Bank of New York survey released this week.
The September Survey of Consumer Expectations put expected household spending growth at 5.5 percent, the highest since May 2023, while expected income growth inched up to just 3.1 percent. Inflation expectations for the year ahead rose to 3.9 percent, and larger shares of respondents said they were worse off than a year ago and expected to be worse off a year from now.
One figure explains the anxiety: more than half of consumers said their savings would last three months or less without income. Job-loss fears actually eased in the survey, according to the report, but price fears more than replaced them.
Economists watch this gap between expected spending and expected income closely, because it signals households bracing for higher bills rather than planning bigger purchases. That is a squeeze, not a boom — and it tends to show up later as softer discretionary spending.
For the Federal Reserve, sticky household inflation expectations are the number that matters most. If families believe prices will keep rising at this pace, they behave in ways that make it so, which is why surveys like this one carry weight far beyond their sample size.
The survey’s most underappreciated signal sits inside the job numbers. Fear of job loss eased while fear of prices climbed, which describes an anxiety that has changed character: Americans are not bracing for the pink slip, they are bracing for the receipt. That distinction matters for policy, because an economy anxious about employment responds to rate cuts, while an economy anxious about prices mostly responds to prices — a slower, supply-side conversation the central bank does not control.
Retailers reading this survey will plan their winter accordingly. Demand for the obligatory will hold; demand for the discretionary will be negotiated item by item, at whatever income line the 5.5 percent expectation meets the 3.1 percent reality. The gap between those two numbers is, in effect, the holiday season’s margin.
Related reading:
